Kevin Gee writes a thoughtful OpEd piece,
Wireless Traffic, in
The Shorthorn Online (University of Texas Arlington) regarding someone's proposal/opinion that UTA become a laptop university. The
bandwagon argument
pro moving to laptops at UTA includes: improved student productivity, enhance education and learning through better collaboration, and reducing the digital divide.
Gee makes his case and concludes "I should stress: I’m not anti-laptops. I think that they are a useful tool, if used appropriately, and my experience is that most university students really don’t need one. Those who find they need one can buy one for about the price of a three-hour graduate course."
The battle lines are forming with schools looking like early adopters...but the arguments seem to fall within four basic categories: economic issues for student, economic issues for the institution, security of networks, managing connectivity in the classroom, and impact on learning.
There are certainly issues in moving to a wireless and laptop campus:- Virus protection - the potential that someone at a Starbucks picks up a computer virus and later infects the campus network
- Hardware Costs - even with increasingly lower priced laptops, the devices are still more expensive than traditional desktop PC's
- Labs - there is an undercurrent of thought running around that argues a move to laptops will eliminate the need for computer labs... specialized propriety software with per seat licenses may be a serious problem in that regard
- Connectivity - just how connected do our students need to be? Is there an expectation that with a laptop in hand that a professor will welcome after hours Instant Messages...or the use of IM's during class? Will a laptop replace the cell phone on campus?
- Damage and Theft - arguably, any computer can be stolen or damaged... but a small, portable, and expensive device makes for a good target... and Desktop PC's are rarely dropped or stepped on in a backpack.
- Laptop Business - Is there an expectation that the university will support a laptop program (maintenance, software support, replacement, loaners)?